Is Cabot New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese vegetarian?
No animal rennet: likely
- Checked
- Nov 8, 2026
- Evidence
- Tier 2, first-party, brand-wide
- Main source
- Email reply from Cabot Creamery Customer Satisfaction, Nov 9, 2026
Looks good, but not certain. The evidence points to no animal rennet. See why below.
Cabot says it uses a microbial-based enzyme for all its cheeses except processed American slices and Shredded Mexican Blend, and that its other cheeses are made without animal rennet. We checked Cabot's FAQ on Nov 8, 2026. This rests on a brand-wide statement.
Evidence
- TIER 2Email reply from Cabot Creamery Customer Satisfaction, Nov 9, 2026first-party, brand-wide
“All Cabot cheeses, with the exception of our American Cheese Slices, are produced using a vegetarian-approved microbial enzyme (rennet).”
- TIER 2Cabot Creamery FAQfirst-party, brand-wide
“Cabot uses a microbial-based enzyme to manufacture all of our award-winning cheeses”
- TIER 2Cabot Creamery FAQfirst-party, brand-wide
“With the exceptions previously noted, Cabot cheeses are made without any animal rennet.”

