Pepper JackCheese type · 38 products
Is pepper jack vegetarian?
What's typical for pepper jack
Animal rennet is uncommon
100% free of animal rennet
38 of 38 checked
Pepper Jack is Monterey Jack with hot peppers, so it follows the same pattern: most US versions are made with FPC or microbial enzymes. Brands such as Tillamook and Sargento say their cheeses, apart from a few listed exceptions, are made without animal rennet. Check store-brand and small-batch versions.
A brand's own answer always beats what's typical, so check the list below.
Sources for this guide
- US standard for Monterey Jack, 21 CFR 133.153
- UW Center for Dairy Research, Dairy Pipeline: Rennet and coagulants, 2012
- Tillamook FAQ: Is Tillamook cheese vegetarian friendly?
- Sargento FAQ
Guide last checked Nov 7, 2026.
Products
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Shredded Pepper Jack Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Sliced Pepper Jack, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Pepper Jack Deli Sliced Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Double Pepper Monterey Jack Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Organics Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Select Ingredients Monterey Jack Cheese with Jalapenos, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese, Extra Thin, 6.84 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Lucerne Ghost Pepper Sliced Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Lucerne Shredded Pepper Jack, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Pepper Jackchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Organic Jalapeño Jackchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Sierra Jack Habanerochecked No animal rennet: verified
- Wegmans Pepper Jack Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Cabot Pepper Jack Cheese Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Pepper Jack Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Pepper Jack Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Pepper Jack Snack Stickschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cedar Grove Cheese Cedar Grove Pepper Jackchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Clover Sonoma Organic Pepper Jack Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Pepper Jack Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- First Street Pepper Jack Monterey Jack Cheese with Jalapeño Peppers Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- First Street Pepper Jack Monterey Jack Sliced Cheese with Jalapeño Pepperschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Pepper Jack Cheese Stickschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Pepper Jack Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Pepper Jack Cheese Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Pepper Jack Cheese Slices, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Red Apple Cheese Pepper Jack Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Pepper Jack Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Pepper Jack Cheese Sticks, 12-Countchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sargento Colby-Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese, 11 Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sargento Ultra Thin Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese, 18 Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sliced Pepper Jackchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Spring Haven Farms Pepper Jack Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Pepper Jack Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Pepper Jack Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Pepper Jack Farmstyle Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sliced Hot Habanero Jack and Pepper Jackchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sliced Pepper Jackchecked No animal rennet: likely
