Is First Street Mild Cheddar Thick Sliced Cheese vegetarian?
No animal rennet: likely
- Checked
- Nov 21, 2026
- Evidence
- Tier 2, first-party, brand-wide
- Main source
- USDA FoodData Central listing 2611807 (First Street)
Looks good, but not certain. The evidence points to no animal rennet. See why below.
The ingredient list filed with USDA's FoodData Central for this First Street product names microbial enzymes, not animal rennet. We re-checked the listing on Nov 21, 2026; it is more than two years old, so check the package when it matters to you.

Evidence
- TIER 2USDA FoodData Central listing 2611807 (First Street)first-party, brand-wide
“CULTURED PASTEURIZED MILK, SALT, ENZYMES (MICROBIAL), ANNATTO (VEGETABLE”
