Is Jasper Hill Farm Bayley Hazen Blue vegetarian?
Contains animal rennet
- Checked
- Nov 7, 2026
- Evidence
- Tier 1, first-party, this product
- Main source
- Jasper Hill Farm (email reply)
Not this one. The evidence below says it uses animal rennet.
Jasper Hill Farm says it makes its own rennet from calf stomach as the coagulant for its raw milk cheeses, and lists Bayley Hazen Blue among them. We checked the maker's Creameries page on Nov 7, 2026. The page describes the raw milk line as a whole rather than naming this cheese's coagulant.

Evidence
- TIER 1Jasper Hill Farm (email reply)first-party, this product
“All of our cheeses are made with traditional animal rennet with the exception of the Cabot Clothbound Cheddar which uses a microbial rennet.”
- TIER 2Jasper Hill Farm, The Creameries pagefirst-party, brand-wide
“We create a de-albuminized whey known as Recuitte that then is mixed with calf vells—strips of a cow’s fourth stomach or abomasum.”
- TIER 2Jasper Hill Farm, The Creameries pagefirst-party, brand-wide
“The result is a coagulant that deepens the umami characteristics of our raw milk cheeses.”
- TIER 2Jasper Hill Farm, The Creameries pagefirst-party, brand-wide
“Our raw milk cheeses—Alpha Tolman, Bayley Hazen Blue, Whitney, and Winnimere—are produced at this creamery.”
- TIER 1Jasper Hill: The Creameriesfirst-party, this product
“In addition to our carry-over cultures, we are producing our very own rennet.”
