Is Organic Valley Vermont Organic Extra Sharp Cheddar vegetarian?
No animal rennet: likely
- Checked
- Nov 8, 2026
- Evidence
- Tier 2, first-party, brand-wide
- Main source
- Email from Organic Valley consumer relations (Nov 2, 2026)
Looks good, but not certain. The evidence points to no animal rennet. See why below.
Organic Valley told us on Nov 2, 2026 that it uses microbial enzymes in all its cheese varieties. This rests on that brand-wide reply, which is newer than a 2018 label listing that named animal rennet.

Evidence
- TIER 2USDA FoodData Central listing 1850739 (ORGANIC VALLEY, VERMONT ORGANIC EXTRA SHARP CHEDDAR CHEESE)first-party, brand-wide
“ORGANIC PASTEURIZED CULTURED MILK, SALT, ANIMAL RENNET”
- TIER 2Email from Organic Valley consumer relations (Nov 2, 2026)first-party, brand-wide
“We use microbial enzymes in all our cheese varieties.”
- TIER 2Organic Valley blog: What Is Cheese?first-party, brand-wide
“Organic Valley uses vegetarian rennet enzymes in all its cheeses.”
