What is FPC?
FPC stands for fermentation-produced chymosin. It's the enzyme that turns milk into curds in many cheeses, and it's made without animals. Here's the full rundown on what it is, why some people avoid it, and what's true about the claims you may have seen online. This happens to be a controversial topic that's been amplified by social media influencers.
The short answer
- FPC is chymosin, the main enzyme in calf rennet, but it's made by microbes instead of taken from a calf's stomach.
- No animal is killed to make it, so most vegetarians are cool with it and eat cheese made with it. Personally, we are fine with FPC.
- Some hard-core vegetarians avoid it because the recipe for the enzyme originally comes from a calf gene, and/or because it's made with genetic engineering. Rennet Scout marks FPC on the cheeses that use it (when we can find that info), so you can filter it out if you want.
How FPC is made
Scientists copy the calf's gene for chymosin into a microbe. US rules name three microbes:
(1) a lab strain of E. coli bacteria,
(2) a dairy yeast (Kluyveromyces lactis)
(3) a mold (Aspergillus niger) (source).
The microbes grow in fermentation tanks and make the enzyme, the same way yeast makes beer or bread rise (source).
The enzyme is then separated and purified. When the FDA reviewed the first FPC in 1990, it found that processing destroys the microbe and removes most of its cellular material (source). Europe's food safety agency reached the same kind of conclusion in 2022, finding a current FPC free of living production cells and of the modified DNA (source).
Is it safe?
We think so. Here's why: regulators have looked at it for more than 30 years. The FDA affirmed FPC as "generally recognized as safe" in 1990 and approved a second version in 1993 (source) (source). The UN's food additive experts (JECFA) reviewed chymosin in 1990 without setting a limit on intake (source), and EFSA found no safety concerns in 2022 (source).
How common is it?
Super common. Estimates for US cheese range from about 70% (2008) (source) to over 80% in North America (2024) (source). We haven't found a recent official figure, so treat these as estimates. Cheesemakers like it because it works most like calf rennet and costs less (source). We like it because no baby animals have to die.
Is FPC vegetarian?
We'd like to give you a simple yes/no, but it depends on whom you ask.
- Most vegetarians: yes, since no animal is harmed and none of the cheese comes from an animal's stomach. This is where we at Rennet Scout stand on the issue.
- The Vegetarian Resource Group says some vegetarians accept FPC and others don't (source). One of its researchers has written that she personally doesn't consider it vegetarian (source).
- The Vegetarian Society (UK) accepts vegetarian rennet in cheese, but doesn't allow genetically modified ingredients in products carrying its trademark (source).
- Kosher: genetically engineered rennet is used to make kosher cheese (source).
On Rennet Scout, FPC counts as "no animal rennet," but we try to flag it when we know, so you can hide FPC cheeses when you search if you'd like.
FPC vs. microbial rennet
They're really easy to mix up. Traditional microbial rennet comes from molds such as Rhizomucor miehei, which make their own milk-clotting enzymes. It isn't calf chymosin and involves no calf gene (source). FPC is the calf enzyme, made by microbes. To add to the confusion, the industry often calls both "microbial rennet" (source), which is why some cheesemakers now say "non-GMO microbial rennet" when they mean the mold kind.
USDA Organic rules don't allow enzymes from microbes developed through genetic engineering (source), so organic cheese shouldn't use FPC. Organic rules do still allow animal rennet, though, so you can't just search for organic cheese.
Is my cheese made by Pfizer?
No, but that's a good line if you are an online influencer trying to get some views. Claims like this usually have a grain of truth, though... Pfizer did have a food science business a long time ago and they did develop the first FPC, called Chy-Max, in the late 1980s (source). So that's where the Pfizer claim comes from. The FDA approved it in 1990 (source) and the Chy-Max business was sold off soon after (to the Danish company Chr. Hansen) (source). Around that time, Pfizer sold the rest of its food science business to the Finnish company Cultor (source). In 2012 it also sold its infant nutrition business to Nestlé (source). Pfizer hasn't made cheese enzymes for about 30 years.
Is FPC cheese made in a lab?
We don't think that's a fair characterization, but it's another good line for social media attention. Thousands of cheesemakers, big and small, still make cheese the usual way, with milk, cultures, salt and time. The lab work to create FPC happened years ago when scientists gave a microbe the gene for chymosin. The microbe copies that gene on its own every time it divides. The enzyme is grown in fermentation tanks, much like beer is brewed, and then purified. Safety reviews in the US and Europe found that no living microbes remain in the finished enzyme (source) (source). Europe's review also found none of the modified DNA (source).
You probably already eat and use plenty of products made this way. Most of the citric acid in soda and candy comes from fermenting the same mold that's used by one of the major FPC brands. Microbe-made enzymes help make bread, beer, fruit juice and other stuff. Cheese itself has always relied on microbes, and FPC is just one more ingredient made with their help.
For us at Rennet Scout, a microbe that carries the chymosin gene is a good alternative to animal-based rennet. We don't consider our cheese to be "made in a lab." If you have the opportunity to visit a cheesemaker and watch the process, we think you'll probably come to the same conclusion.
Watch how cheese is made:
Can I tell from the label?
Usually not. US rules let cheese labels list any clotting enzyme, whether from an animal, a plant or a microbe, as just "enzymes" (source). That's why we ask the makers. Look for the FPC note on any cheese page here, or search the cheese finder and hide FPC cheeses.
New to all this? Start with What is rennet?
