CheddarCheese type · 450 products
Is cheddar vegetarian?
What's typical for cheddar
Animal rennet is uncommon
97% free of animal rennet
435 of 450 checked
Most cheddar sold in the US is made with fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC) or microbial enzymes rather than calf rennet. Some aged and traditional cheddars still use animal rennet, so long-aged and extra sharp cheddars are the ones to check: Tillamook's 10-year cheddar is its one exception. US labels may just say "enzymes," which can mean any source.
A brand's own answer always beats what's typical, so check the list below.
Sources for this guide
- US standard for cheddar cheese, 21 CFR 133.113
- UW Center for Dairy Research, Dairy Pipeline: Rennet and coagulants, 2012
- Vegetarian Resource Group: An Update on Rennet, 2008
- Tillamook FAQ: Is Tillamook cheese vegetarian friendly?
- Cabot Creamery help center: Making cheese
Guide last checked Nov 7, 2026.
Cheddar is my favorite!
Products
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Sliced Mild Cheddar Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Sliced Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Sharp Cheddar Bar, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shredschecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Sharp Cheddar Slice, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Sliced Reduced Fat Mild Cheddar, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Cheese Cracker with Hidden Veggieschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Deluxe Classic Cheddar Microwavable Cupschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Deluxe Rich & Creamy Shells & Aged Cheddar Mac & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Cheddar Bunnieschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Cheddar Snack Mixchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Cheddar Squareschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Extra Cheesy Cheddar Bunnieschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Grass Fed Classic Cheddar Mac & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Grass Fed Shells & Real Aged Cheddar Mac & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic Macaroni & Classic Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Organic White Cheddar Bunnieschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Puppies & Kitties & White Cheddar Pasta & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Shells & Real Aged Cheddar Mac & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Shells & White Cheddar Mac & Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Shells & White Cheddar Mac & Cheese, Family Size, 10.5 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Sweet & Salty Snack Variety Packchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Annie's Yummy Bunnies & Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Babybel Mini White Cheddar Varietychecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Apple Walnut Smokedchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Barely Buzzedchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Big John's Cajunchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Pour Me A Slicechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Promontorychecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Queen Bee Porcinichecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Red Butte Hatch Chilechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Seahivechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Teahivechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Beehive Cheese Co. Trufflehivechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Cabot Cabot Clothbound Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Cabot Private Stock Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Clover Sonoma Medium Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: verified
- COWS Creamery COWS Creamery Avonlea Clothbound Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Gibbsville Cheese Gibbsville Natural Rindless Cheddar with Garlic & Dillchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Gibbsville Cheese Gibbsville Natural Rindless Medium Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Gibbsville Cheese Gibbsville Natural Rindless Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Gibbsville Cheese Gibbsville Natural Rindless Super Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Finely Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Good & Gather Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Cheese Cubes, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 9 oz/12 ctchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Good & Gather Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Good & Gather Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Medium Cheddar Cheese Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Sharp Cheddar Cracker-Cut Cheese, 10 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Sharp Cheddar Deli Sliced Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Shredded Medium Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Good & Gather Shredded Triple Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Ched Over Heelschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Cheddar Weatherchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Cheddy Mac Cupschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Gluten-Free Cheddy Macchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Hotshot Jackpotchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Queso Tell Me Morechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Shell We Dancechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Smokey Dokeychecked No animal rennet: verified
- Goodles Thrilled Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Longhorn Style Cheddar Cheese, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Medium Cheddar Cheese, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Organics Mild Cheddar Shredded Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B H-E-B Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheese, Thick Cut, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Hill Country Fare Mild Cheddar Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Hill Country Fare Mild Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 10 ctchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 10 ctchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- H-E-B Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 10 ctchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Kirkland Signature Kirkland Signature Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 2 lb Blockchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Land O'Lakes Land O Lakes Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Land O'Lakes Land O Lakes Sharp Cheddar Farmstyle Cut Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Lucerne Finely Shredded Triple Cheddar, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Lucerne Lucerne Shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Lucerne Shredded Sharp Cheddar WI-NY-VT Blend, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Maplebrook Farm Maplebrook Cheddar Biteschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Marcoot Jersey Creamery Marcoot White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery 4 Alarm Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Black Pepper Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Caramelized Onion Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Cheddar Reservechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Garden Vegetable Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Old Style Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Prairie Breezechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Milton Creamery Milton Creamery Tomato Garlic Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- O Organics White Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Croc Bites Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snackschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Extra Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Grand Reserve Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Smoked Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Old Croc Old Croc Variety Cheese Variety Packchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Flavor Favorites Spicy Cheddar Slices, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Grassmilk Raw Cheddar Cheese, Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Medium Cheddar Cheese Stickschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Mild Cheddar Cheese, Thick Cut Shredded, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Raw Mild Cheddar, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Raw Sharp Cheddar, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Thick Cut Shredded, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Smoky Cheddar Cheese, Sliced, Flavor Favorites, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Spicy Cheddar Cheese, Shredded, Flavor Favorites, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Organic Valley Organic Valley Raw Sharp Cheddar Slices, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Publix Publix Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 12 ctchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Redhead Creamery Redhead Creamery Garlic Clothbound Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Redhead Creamery Redhead Creamery Margie Clothbound Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Redhead Creamery Redhead Creamery Red Temper Honey Chipotle Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Redhead Creamery Redhead Creamery Simply Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Rogue Creamery Cheese Is Lovechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Rogue Creamery Jefferson Aged Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Farmhouse Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Italian Herb Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Italian Herb Cheese Biteschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Jalapeño Ranch Cheese Biteschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Montamore Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori MontAmoré Cheese Biteschecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Old World Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sartori Sriracha Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Organic Farmhouse White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Simple Truth Organic Sharp White Cheddar Block Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Simple Truth Simple Truth Organic Finely Shredded White Cheddar Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Taste of Inspirations Imported English Cheddar Cheese Wedge, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Tillamook Medium Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Wegmans Reduced Fat 2% Milk Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Wegmans Wegmans Irish Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: verified
- Wegmans Wegmans Sliced Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Family Packchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Wholesome Pantry Wholesome Pantry Organic Mild Cheddar Cheese Slices, 8 ct, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: verified
- Abbey Farms Imported Extra Sharp Welsh Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Applegate Medium Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Applegate Mild Cheddar Organic Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Applegate Shredded Medium Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Barber's Vintage Reserve Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beecher's Handmade Cheese Extra Aged Flagship Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Cheese Stickschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Reservechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beecher's Handmade Cheese Smoked Flagship Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Beehive Cheese Co. Cheddar Infused with Basil Hayden Bourbon Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Boar's Head Boar's Head Organic Aged White Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Boar's Head Boar's Head Smoked Beechwood Wisconsin Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot 1 Year Cheddar Cracker Cuts, 10 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot 10 Year Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot 3 Year Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot 5 Year Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Alpine Cheddar Cheese Dairychecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Alpine Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Artisan Reserve Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Buffalo Style Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Everything Bagel Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Cheddar Spreadable Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Delichecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Farmhouse Reserve Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Garlic Herb Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Habanero Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Horseradish Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Horseradish Cheddar Spreadable Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snackschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Mac & Cheese Cheddar Cheese Shredded, Classic Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Mild Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Mild Cheddar Cheese Slices (Stacked)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices (Stacked)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Extra Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Slices (Shingle)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot New York Vintage Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Port Wine Cheddar Spreadable Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shredded, Classic Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shredded, Rustic Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices (Shingle)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ctchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar Snack Stickschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Seriously Sharp Yellow Cheddar Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ctchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Smoky Bacon Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Smoky Bacon Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Tuscan Cheddar Cheese Deli Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Two State Farmers' Cheddar Cheese Shredded, Classic Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices (Shingle), 7 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices (Stacked), 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Dairy Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vermont Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cracker Cuts, 10 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot Vintage Choice Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cabot White Oak Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Castello Caramelized Onion Mature Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Castello Chilies & Peppers Extra Mature English Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Castello Cracked Black Pepper Mature Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Castello Extra Mature Devonshire Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cedar Grove Cheese Cedar Grove Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Clover Sonoma Sharp White Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Cobb Hill Cheese Cobb Hill Four Cornerschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Deer Creek Deer Creek The Doechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Deer Creek Deer Creek The Fawnchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Deer Creek Deer Creek The Stagchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Deer Creek Deer Creek Vat 17 World Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Classic Shredded Mild Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Extra Sharp Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded Extra Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded Mild Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded Reduced Fat Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded Triple Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Fancy Shredded White Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Medium Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Mild Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Reduced Fat Sharp Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Sharp Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Thick Cut Mild Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms Thick Cut Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Dutch Farms Dutch Farms White Sharp Cheddar Barchecked No animal rennet: likely
- First Street Extra Sharp Cheddar Cracker Cuts Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- First Street Mild Cheddar Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- First Street Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks Barschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Fiscalini Cheese Co. Craft Beer Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Fiscalini Cheese Co. Truffle Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Ford Farm Aged English Cheddar Style Cheese Naturally Smoked over Oak Shipschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Ford Farm Billie's English Goat Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Ford Farm Farmhouse Cheddar with Mustard & Alechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Ford Farm Seaside English Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Full Circle Market Mild White Cheddar Finely Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Full Circle Market Mild White Cheddar Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Cheddar Cheese Curdschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Creamy Cheddar-Style Semi-Soft Cheese Single Snackschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Garlic Cheddar Cheese Curdschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Classic Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Cracker Cut Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Extra-Thin Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Feather Cut Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Mild Cheddar Reduced Fat Classic Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Organic Finely Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather Three Cheddar Blend Feather Cut Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Good & Gather White Mild Cheddar Cracker Cut Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton 1 Year Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton 2 Year Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton Clothbound Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton Maple Smoked Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton Smoked Chili Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Grafton Village Cheese Grafton Truffle Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Happy Farms Medium Cheddar Deli-Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Happy Farms Sriracha Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter 2% Milk Reduced Fat Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Chunk, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Gourmet Sharp Cheddar Blend Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Medium Cheddar Cheese, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Shredded Aged Sharp White Cheddar Cheese, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Harris Teeter Very Thin Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 6.84 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Harris Teeter Thick Cut Wisconsin Extra Sharp Cheddar Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Heber Valley Artisan Cheese Heber Valley Tomato Basil Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Heinen's Aged 15 Months Vintage Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Heinen's Red Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese 12 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese 13 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese - Whitechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Aleppo Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Apple Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Black Garlic Peppercorn Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Blazing Buffalo Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Blueberry Cobbler Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Bourbon Cask Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Caraway Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Chipotle Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Cranberry Orange Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Dragon's Breath Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Henning's Cheese Henning's Extra Sharp 8 Year Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hill Country Fare Mild Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hill Valley Dairy Hill Valley Dairy Mild Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hill Valley Dairy Hill Valley Dairy Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hill Valley Dairy Hill Valley Dairy Whiskey Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hook's Cheese Company Ten Year Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hook's Cheese Company Twelve Year Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Hook's Cheese Company Two Year Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Ivy's Reserve Vintage Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Dublinerchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Kerrygold Aged Cheddar Cheese Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Kerrygold Aged Cheddar Cheese Snackschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Kerrygold Extra Sharp White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Kerrygold Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Mild Cheddar 100% Natural Shredded Creamy Irish Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Mild Cheddar Creamy Irish Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Savory Cheddar Rich & Smooth Irish Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kerrygold Savory Cheddar Rich & Smooth Irish Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Lye Cross Farm Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- McCall's Chive Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- McCall's Grassfed Irish Oak Smoked Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- McCall's Grassfed Irish Porter Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- McCall's Grassfed Irish Whiskey Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- McLelland Extra Mature Scottish Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- McLelland Vintage Scottish Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Meyenberg Goat Milk Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Mull of Kintyre Extra Mature Scottish Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Medium Cheddar Cheese Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Medium Cheddar Cheese Slices, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Mild Cheddar Cheese Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese Shreds, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Natural Grocers Natural Grocers Organic Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices, 6 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Nature's Basket White Cheddar Organic Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- O Organics Finely Shredded Organic Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- O Organics Organic White Sharp Cheddar Finely Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Old Croc Chipotle & Onion Aged Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Old Croc Classic Australian Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Old Croc Classic Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Organic Valley Vermont Organic Extra Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- ParmCrisps ParmCrisps Cheddar Multipackchecked No animal rennet: likely
- ParmCrisps ParmCrisps Cheddar Pouchchecked No animal rennet: likely
- ParmCrisps ParmCrisps Cheddar Tubchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Private Selection Aged Cheddar Blend Thick Cut Shreddedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Private Selection Sharp White Cheddar Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Publix Publix New York Style Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Publix Publix Reduced Fat Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheese, 8 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Publix Sharp Cheddar Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Raw Farm Truly Raw Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Red Apple Cheese Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Red Apple Cheese Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Borderline Blaze Smoked Jalapeño Pepper Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Mild Cheddar Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Rumiano Medium Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Rumiano Cheese Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Balanced Breaks White Cheddar, Almonds & Cranberries Snack Kitchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Creamery Sliced Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 12-Countchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Mild Cheddar Cheese Cubes, 16 ozchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Reduced Fat Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 12-Countchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Reserve Series Shredded 18-Month Aged Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sargento Reserve Series Aged White Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 10 Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sargento Smokehouse Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 11 Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sargento Ultra Thin Sharp Cheddar Sliced Cheese, 18 Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks, 12-Countchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Shredded Cheddar (Mild, Medium, Sharp, Extra Sharp)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Shredded Creamery Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sargento Sliced Cheddar (Mild, Medium, Sharp)checked No animal rennet: likely
- Shaft's Serendipity Aged Blue + Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Organic Raw Milk White Cheddar Grass-Fedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Raw Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Smoked Cheddar Organic Grass-Fed Raw Milkchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Smoked Goat Cheddar Raw Milk Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Simple Truth Organic Sharp White Cheddar Slicedchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Singletons & Co Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Singletons & Co Jalapeño & Garlic Cheddar Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Singletons & Co Oak-Smoked Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Singletons & Co Vintage Cheddar Handmade English Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Smith's Country Cheese Farmstead Sharp Cheddar Raw Milk Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Snowdonia Cheese Company Black Bomber Extra Mature Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Snowdonia Cheese Company Bouncing Berry Mature Cheddar with Cranberrieschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Snowdonia Cheese Company Green Thunder Mature Cheddar with Garlic and Herbschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Snowdonia Cheese Company Nature's Nectar Mature Cheddar with Rum Marinated Figs and Honeychecked No animal rennet: likely
- Snowdonia Cheese Company Rock Star Vintage Cave-Aged Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Somerdale Black Cow Deluxe Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Somerdale Bloody Good Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Somerdale Cheddar Aged Irish Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Somerdale Red Dragon Cheddar Cheese with Wholegrain Mustard & Alechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Spring Haven Farms Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Table One Goat Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- The Cheese Guy Craft Beer Cheddar Vt Artisan Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Cheddar Curdschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Extra Sharp White Cheddar Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection English-Style Sweet Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Extra Sharp Aged Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Extra Sharp Aged White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Garlic Chili Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Hickory Smoked Extra Sharp White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Smoked Black Pepper White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmers' Collection Truffle White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmstyle Shredded Sharp Cheddar Thick Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmstyle Shredded Sharp White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Farmstyle Shredded Triple Cheddar Blend Thick Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Hickory Smoked Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Kosher Medium Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Maker's Reserve 3-Year Extra Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Maker's Reserve Aged Sweet Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Medium Cheddar Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Medium Cheddar Farmstyle Shredded Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Medium Cheddar Portionschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Medium White Cheddar Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sharp Cheddar Baby Loafchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sharp Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sharp Cheddar Cracker Cutschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Blockchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sharp White Cheddar Portionschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Shredded Double Cheddar Blend Fine Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Shredded Extra Sharp Triple White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Shredded Sharp Cheddar Fine Cutchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sliced Extra Sharp White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Sliced Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Smoked Black Pepper Portionschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Medium Cheddar Deli Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sharp Cheddar Deli Sliceschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sliced Medium Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sliced Medium White Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Tillamook Tillamook Sliced Smoked Medium Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Vella Cheese Company Vella Daisy Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Vella Cheese Company Vella Sharp Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Westminster Hand Select Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Westminster Reserve Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Westminster Smoked Cheddar English Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Westminster Special Edition Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Westminster Vintage Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Whisps Whisps Cheddar Cheese Crispschecked No animal rennet: likely
- Wild Harvest Sharp White Cheddar Organic Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Wyke Farms Smoked Extra Mature Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Wyke Farms Vintage Reserve Cheddar Cheesechecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Bacon Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Chesapeake Bay Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Ghost Pepper Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Horseradish Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Roasted Garlic Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Yancey's Fancy Yancey's Fancy Wasabi Horseradish Cheddarchecked No animal rennet: likely
- Kraft Singles (Cheddar)checked Contains animal rennet
- Redhead Creamery Redhead Creamery Lucky Linda Clothbound Cheddarchecked Contains animal rennet
- Shelburne Farms Shelburne Farms Cheddarchecked Contains animal rennet
- Tillamook Maker's Reserve 10-Year Extra Sharp Cheddarchecked Contains animal rennet
- Black Diamond Cheddarchecked Unknown
- Boar's Head Bold Horseradish Cheddar Cheesechecked Unknown
- Boar's Head Sharp Cheddarchecked Unknown
- Boar's Head Vermont White Cheddarchecked Unknown
- Boar's Head Wisconsin Cheddarchecked Unknown
- Boar's Head Yellow Cheddarchecked Unknown
- Trader Joe's Trader Joe's Chive Cheddar Cheesechecked Unknown
- Trader Joe's Trader Joe's Coastal Cheddar Cheese with Trufflechecked Unknown
- Trader Joe's Trader Joe's New Zealand Sharp Cheddar Cheesechecked Unknown
- Trader Joe's Trader Joe's Shredded Unexpected Cheddar Cheesechecked Unknown
- Trader Joe's Trader Joe's Unexpected Cheddar Cheesechecked Unknown
